What's a Pooka?
This week's movie features James Stewart in his best role, as Elwood Dowd, the man with an invisible friend. One of the few comedies of my youth that are still hilarious in the autumn of my years: Harvey. My one quible with the movie is that, at first glance, it seems to somewhat glorify drinking. I don't like the idea that Elwood is a drunk. So I'm going to practice intense Personal Movie Revisionism to rationalize away my nagging feeling of cognitive dissonance. Ostensibly, drinking gives Elwood a wonderful personality. And, it's Elwood's wonderful personality that kindles the affection everyone has for this film. This is problematic. Have you ever known anyone to become a wonderful human being because they drink? I mean not just in the drunk's own mind, but to those around him. However, pay close attention to what goes on in the movie and you'll see his character actually has little or nothing to do with alcohol. In fact, it seems obvious that Elwood is not an alcoholic at all. (And I speak as one who knows alcohol.) You never see him stagger or hear him slur his speech. The problems that his sisters attribute to alcoholism turn out to be not problems at all. He invites everyone he meets to come over for dinner, not because he's drunk but because he likes everyone he meets, he sees the good in them. And, as we find out, Harvey, the giant, invisible bunny---who initially appears to be a gentle gift of the DT's---is not so imaginary after all. Elwood does enjoy a drink, but he retains his lovable qualities despite hours without a drink at the asylum. If anything, his ability to accept everyone and resent nothing makes him more of an enlightened saint than an alcoholic.
The line that best expresses the theme of the film comes when Elwood relates what his mother told him:
She said, "In this world, Elwood, you must be either oh so smart or oh so pleasant." Well, for years I was smart---I recommend pleasant.
So that's my preferred take on what's really going on in the movie. Elwood isn't a deluded alcoholic, he's an enlightened being walking among us accompanied by a minor woodland deity. But don't take my word for it, rent Harvey, then, if you need to, look up "Pooka" in the dictionary...